Saturday, 22 March 2014

Credit Crunch and Minsky Moment

The term “Credit Crunch” can be defined as “a severe shortage of money or credit”. Credit Crunch and recession always go hand in hand.

People learn from their past experience and try to prevent not to happen again. It should be the same in the business world too. In history, there were a number of financial crisis. All were originated from the credit crisis. But the question is “Have we all learned? “.

In my opinion, it looks it does not. Since the fall of the US housing market in 2007, the credit problem had escalated and spread to many countries. UK had also suffered.

During a recession, the spending power of people falls and this has led business into unprofitable situation which makes people unemployed.  That means people are not able to spend as they use to. Thus makes circling and it takes years to remedy the situation.

The change of bank lending behaviour was the main cause of the recent crisis in 2008. The US Government policy of housing development for poor was one of the culprits which contributed the change of bank lending behaviour. Relaxing a lot of regulation for the buyers in the housing market had influenced the bank decision in giving out loan.  The lack of governance in regulation had caused the bank to give loans to the people whose financial positions were not fit enough.

In reality, the borrowers were not able to return when it was due; the bank suffered the loss of loan. To offset the risk, the bank increased the interest rate which made cost of borrowing was increased. This made the situation even worse.  The lenders were reluctant to finance. 2007 Crisis had brought the same situation. The banks were reluctant to borrow money to each other. In this scenario, the involvement of government was very important. A good example is the Northern Rock Bank in UK. Finally, the Bank of England had to fund the bank.

The lack of governance in lending regulation has pushed the mortgage advisor to make unethical decision. The more they have made the business profitable, the more they can enjoy the commission. This encourages them to bring more borrowers/ customers regardless of their financial background.

Regulators are important in governing the lending decision. All the parties must understand the responsible lending. The IT sector are also looking into this matter and trying to observe the best way to tackle. According to financial service technology, analyse house OVUM claim that it is foreseeable the end of credit crunch will be in 2018. According to Daniel Mayo, the practice leader, OVUM says "Lending is picking up and banks are looking to IT to analyse and understand lending decisions in order to minimise the risk of another financial crisis. This increase in responsible lending suggests that the end of the credit crunch is in sight."

As credit crunch can cause damage to economy, all parties involved; the economists, the analyst should monitor carefully after a long credit expansion in a country. For example, China

China builds their economy on debt. The threat is it is possible to burst. However due to the recent inflow of the China FDI into domestic market, it appears it is still manageable.


Therefore, the two Analysts, Morgan Stanley’s Cyril Moulle-Berteaux and Sergei Parmenov argue that China is approaching to its “Minsky Moment” (via Zerohedge).

Minsky Moment is a phenomenon named after the economist Hyman Minsky articulated  the periods of speculation and credit growth inflate assets, only to end in crisis.



Some economists and analysts reject their view, they say China is not in Minsky moment. However, the recent news about the steel mills’ credit squeeze in China (South China Morning Post) and China solar faces credit crunch (Forbes) are depicting China is under the threat which can lead to economic downturn.

Furthermore, as always history tells the truth, therefore, it is not possible to say China will not be affected by Minsky Movement. But it is not deniable it would worth to watch with care.

Reference:


No comments:

Post a Comment